I ranted on Tumblr. It's been a while since I had a good rant, so I'm going to share it here as well. (Also because comments = validation and love, and tumblr is not a place for comments.)
Apparently there is nothing that sets me off nearly as much as when people talk about bodies as meatsuits, or otherwise imply that the body is there to service the brain and the thinking thoughts that enable us to have a concept of self.
Someone posted
a photo of the brain and nervous system laid out on a table and wrote:
This is you. This is where all your thoughts are kept. Every other part of your body is used to protect and sustain this.
A lot of people (93,665 and counting) seem to agree with this sentiment. One of them added:
it’s weirdly comforting to know that all of the meaningless bullshit society judges me on is just a meatsuit made to support the terrifying tentacle beast that is my true form
My reply:
As much as I love the idea of a tentacle beast inside us all, it makes me sort of sad to see mind body dualism alive and well. Even if the mind is perhaps considered to consist
of the brain and nervous system, rather than being merely attached
to it somehow by unclear metaphysics.
I am not just my brain, I am not just my thoughts. I am my fingers and toes and my stomach and spleen. I am the blood in my veins, I am lymph in my ducts. I am the beating of my heart, and the breathing of my lungs.
If I am in the habit of thinking of myself as that which is thinking, well, that’s because I have to think to have a thought.
If I am in the habit of thinking of myself as a verbal and visual creature, well, that’s because I have a mouth and ears and eyes. The thoughts that I articulate to myself, I sub-vocalize using my vocal chords and I hear them with my ears. The pictures I imagine, I visualize using the nerves that join my eyes and my brain.
If I sometimes feel I live in my head, that’s because my eyes and my ears and vocal chords are all in my head and neck.
If I can conceptually differentiate between my self as a body and my self as a mind, that’s because my mind specializes in making conceptual distinctions.
The concept of a mind is the thought I give to the part of me that does the thinking, and is aware of the passing of time.
The concept of the body is the thought I give to the part of me which occupies space, and which moves and eats and breathes and shits and LIVES.
If it seems like the concept of a mind is more immediate than that of a body, that’s because the mind is the part I use to form concepts.
But the body is
just as immediate. I don’t just have a thought about pain, I feel pain. I don’t just have a thought about arousal, I feel aroused. I don’t just think about eating, I feel hungry. I don’t just think about scratching, I have an itch.
My hands, my feet. My hopes, my dreams.
All of this is me.
Link: http://ironed-orchid.dreamwidth.org/652722.html. You may want to check the security settings there, or click to see a content related icon. Read
:comments. Leave a comment using OpenID.